Our Feedback

Finally, an actual good slice of pizza in South Amboy! The vodka chicken Parm is great, the grandma Sicilian was amazing. The sauce is appropriately tangy (not sickly sweet like other places in town). I can't believe it took me this long to find this spot, but I'm glad I have.
- Jay

Great food with great prices. You really can’t go wrong with whatever you order here. My personal favorites are the grandma pie and regular with cherry peppers and sausage 👍🏻
- Mike S

First time here and the pan cheese pie was delicious, fresh and ready when they told me it would be.
- Michele D

We have Been ordering this for a year now. Margherita Pie From J&S gets my 5 stars .
-T M

Hidden gem, got the grandma pie to go and didn't disappoint. Great flavor, perfect garlic kick and crust with actual flavor. Would pick over the other big name places in town
- David Mazurek

I keep coming back to J & S and I’m not disappointed. It’s been a while since I ordered, due to work being cut back. Fresh mushrooms and red onion pizza and breaded wings! Yum! They ingredients are good quality.. I love this place! Hard working family business and their prices are very good compared to other places that use a lesser quality cheese and preparation. Always very polite and gracious!
- Christine Fury

I grew up here and visit family. I always make a point in stopping here. Just a plain slice or two. That's the acid test of any pizzeria. Don't need Buffalo Chicken, or Cheese Steak pies. J&S reminds me of the time that S. Amboy used
- Thaddeus K

Wonderful owner! Pizza was delicious and probably some of the best garlic knots around!! Definitely stop in and support a small family run business!!
- Tooth Fairy

It amazes me how hard it is to find a pizzeria that actually listens to your "well done" request. J&S has yet to fail us and it's definitely why we have stopped going to other local spots who repeatedly sent us floppy (to us) pies. Even when we order for delivery, the pizza still arrives perfectly crisp. These guys sure know how to make a well done pie! Super consistent!
- Olga Cotos-Aguilar

The pizza is always great. The best pizza in the area. Seriously have no complaints. I have tried to find a good pizzeria around here for a while and a friend recommended this place. I was impressed the first time just ordering a PLAIN PIE... every other kind I've tried has also been equally delicious. This will always be my go to place!
- EdensRage

Extremely decent quality food and prices. Definitely the best pizzeria in the area as far as that goes. But I will say that it’s a lot safer to pick up that food instead of having it delivered, since some of the drivers are, well, easily confused.
- Kyle Wavro

Extremely decent quality food and prices. Definitely the best pizzeria in the area as far as that goes. But I will say that it’s a lot safer to pick up that food instead of having it delivered, since some of the drivers are, well, easily confused.
- Kyle Wavro

One of the best cheesesteaks around. Always juicy and flavorful. Service is impeccable and always fast. Also one of the best pizzas around too. Owner and staff are always friendly and you feel like family when you walk in.
- Tim Damiani

It's our 1st visit to NJ from Houston, TX, and we wanted some great pizza. We found J&S from the Google reviews and were NOT disappointed! We tried the chicken Buffalo pizza, vodka sauce pizza, and the upside down pizza. I couldn't choose a favorite, they were all fabulous! Very sweet people running the place too. 2 thumbs up and 5 stars!
- MyCup Overflows

Tried a slice of plain cheese and thick crust with bbq chicken. Plain slice was on point. Chrispy crust, great sauce. Want to get full pie next time just to have some for later. Thick crust bbq chicken slice was delicious. One word of caution. That one slice of bbq chicken was a meal in itself. Seriously, I'm 230 and sliced filled me up. Highly recommend.
- Barry Johnson

I just moved to jersey from Brooklyn so I’m very picky about pizza but I have to say, the pepperoni slice I ordered from here was delicious! I was more than pleasantly surprised! My son also really liked his plain slice and he’s quite the picky eater. Will be going back!
- Brittany Rowley